Glacial Information Gaps Impede Resilience to Sea Degree Rise – Eos


Earth’s ice sheets and glaciers are responding quickly to local weather change. Within the years and a long time forward, sea degree rise, pushed partially by melting ice, will have an effect on hundreds of thousands of individuals in U.S. coastal communities and a whole lot of hundreds of thousands extra world wide. The price of adaptation to sea degree change alongside U.S. coastlines alone is anticipated to exceed $1 trillion by 2100 [Neumann et al., 2015].

in article 1

Our potential to precisely and actionably mission ice loss and its contributions to sea degree rise requires glaciological data and analysis coordination which are nonetheless unrealized.

Our potential to precisely and actionably project ice loss and its contributions to sea degree rise requires glaciological data and analysis coordination, in addition to efficient data dissemination to decisionmakers, which are nonetheless unrealized. Present advert hoc efforts to satisfy these wants are insufficient, delaying the advantages of scientific analysis for a lot of communities already grappling with elevated coastal flooding and different impacts [Wing et al., 2022]. By way of extra coordinated planning and funding efforts, we will higher serve these communities.

Along with bettering sea degree projections related for coastal mitigation and adaptation responses, increasing our data of glacial processes (together with these influencing mountain glaciers) improves our understanding of how local weather change impacts agriculture, hydropower, ingesting water, fisheries, and ecosystems. For instance, analysis has revealed that mountain glacier retreat alongside the North American West Coast opens new habitat for Pacific salmon, affecting billion-dollar-per-year fisheries [Pitman et al., 2021]. It has additionally proven that the worldwide annual web lack of 240 billion metric tons of ice from mountain glaciers is corresponding to 30% of annual water withdrawals used for trade and 63% of water withdrawals for home makes use of [Huss et al., 2017].

Quite a lot of glaciological data has come about from a increase in glaciological analysis throughout the 2000s, which drew many new researchers to the sphere. Lots of them are asking pressing questions prompted by the invention that Earth’s ice sheets reply to environmental forcing on a lot shorter timescales than beforehand thought.

Critically, a long time of glaciological analysis have supplied large advances towards improved prediction of sea degree change. Nevertheless, main gaps in glaciological understanding, observational knowledge, and technical capability persist and impede efforts to supply actionable predictions of ice loss straight linked to societal penalties (Determine 1). For instance, we have now solely sparse observations from ice sheet boundaries, together with the sides of marine-terminating glaciers and ice sheets the place ocean currents affect ice loss. We lack a fundamental understanding of what occurs between glacier ice and the underlying land, the place topography, sediments, and subglacial water affect ice movement. We additionally lack enough long-term monitoring of local weather situations which are forcing ice sheet change, together with ocean warmth content material, which was lately acknowledged as critically vital to each the Greenland and Antarctic ice sheets.

Fig. 1. Gaps in our understanding of glacier and ice sheet techniques, together with basal sliding, freshwater export, and meltwater infiltration, are represented by dotted strains and happen the place completely different Earth techniques intersect and work together. Credit score: Caitlyn Florentine, tailored from a webinar given by NSF’s Interagency Arctic Research Policy Committee, Glaciers and Sea Degree Collaboration Staff

Regardless of the serious implications of coastal inundation and different ice loss impacts, analysis on Earth’s glaciers and ice sheets stays a low funding precedence within the U.S. scientific enterprise (Determine 2) [Aschwanden et al., 2021]. This low standing will not be for a scarcity of figuring out vital scientific issues or their societal relevance. Certainly, the data gaps famous above have been recognized in quite a few revealed research and are well-known to the scientific group [e.g., Catania et al., 2020; Hock et al., 2017; Noble et al., 2020; Straneo et al., 2019], federal and worldwide funding companies, and scientific organizations. As a substitute, we understand different shortcomings that stymie innovation in glaciology and its contributions to correct projections of ice loss and, by extension, U.S. resilience to sea degree.

Fig. 2. The worldwide imply sea degree (blue curve), in line with data from NASA, has risen steadily in latest a long time. For comparability, the NSF Workplace of Polar Applications’ funding as a share of the overall NSF price range (inexperienced stable curve) and NASA’s Earth Science program price range, which funds cryosphere research, as a share of NASA’s whole price range (inexperienced dashed curve) have dropped lately. NSF funding will increase in 2007–2009 replicate investments throughout the Worldwide Polar 12 months (2007–2008) and throughout the American Restoration and Reinvestment Act in 2009. The full variety of publications showing in Google Scholar that point out each “ice sheets” and “sea degree” (pink curve) can also be proven. Will increase in 2011–2012 might replicate the previous funding will increase; the drop in publications in 2021 might replicate impacts on analysis productiveness from the COVID-19 pandemic.

Tradition, Curriculum, Group, and Funding

Glaciology suffers cultural shortcomings widespread throughout the geosciences, particularly a historic and ongoing lack of gender, ethnic, and racial range.

Glaciology suffers cultural shortcomings widespread throughout the geosciences [Bernard and Cooperdock, 2018; Dutt, 2020], particularly a historic and ongoing lack of gender, ethnic, and racial range that makes the self-discipline inequitable. A part of this downside arises as a result of widespread conceptions of glaciology are rooted in hero-glorifying expeditions led by a small variety of people, whereas the contributions of many others within the subject go underrecognized. This conceptualization narrows the vary of seen function fashions, reduces probabilities for range advantages inside our subject, creates a tone of elitism and exclusivity, and is unethical.

This tradition makes it tough for minoritized researchers (demographic teams relegated to a subordinate standing, no matter their precise numbers) to enter the sphere, contribute productively, and be valued and evaluated pretty, ensuing within the near-complete exclusion of those researchers from glaciology. The dearth of range additionally signifies that decisionmaking and group inside the scientific group are usually not inclusive, making group consensus on analysis priorities harder. The glaciology group should actively take part in rising initiatives which are selling fairness within the geosciences, equivalent to URGE (Unlearning Racism in Geoscience) and Polar Impact, and establishments and funders ought to reinforce the need of self-education about cultural points in science throughout profession ranges, together with for established scientists.

There was a hiring increase in glaciology inside the previous half decade in america, indicating that academia acknowledges the sphere as an vital analysis space. Nevertheless, this hiring increase is concentrated in a comparatively small variety of establishments, with many U.S. universities nonetheless missing analysis on the cryosphere completely. Additional, an emphasis on the cryosphere has not but been built-in into undergraduate geoscience curricula uniformly, obscuring the self-discipline’s significance for a lot of rising scientists. Along with a scarcity of range, this lack of publicity interprets into fewer college students pursuing cryosphere science than are wanted, inequitable illustration within the analysis workforce, and usually much less understanding of the significance of Earth’s cryosphere among the many public.

Progress in glaciology additionally suffers from inadequate funding from federal science companies. Federal funding for non-defense-related analysis and improvement total dropped from 5.8% of the federal budget in 1966 to 1.5% in 2019. And no U.S. science company funds long-term (5+ years) glacier or ice sheet investigations besides the U.S. Geological Survey (USGS), by way of its Benchmark Glacier Project, which has been funded by a patchwork of USGS grants since 1958.

There isn’t any coordinating federal physique with a enough price range, schedule, or scope to focus glaciological analysis on decreasing uncertainty in future sea degree projections.

Throughout the Nationwide Science Basis (NSF), glaciology has no house outdoors of the Workplace of Polar Applications (OPP), in distinction to different fields like atmospheric sciences, oceanography, and Earth sciences which are supported by OPP and different applications. NSF due to this fact lacks the capability to fund science on midlatitude and tropical glaciers that lie between 60°N and 60°S latitude. Moreover, prior to now 5 years, funding for OPP has dipped to less than 6% (<$500 million) of the overall NSF analysis price range (Determine 2), and just one third of the OPP price range goes to analysis due to the excessive prices of supporting polar logistics. This restricted quantity is then unfold throughout all 10 disciplines working within the polar areas. Assuming an equal break up throughout all 10, the utmost annual quantity that glaciology might obtain is roughly $10 million, about 10% of the average cost of a U.S. blockbuster movie. Accessible funding knowledge from NASA are extra restricted, but there was a proportional lower there as nicely: Funding for Earth science analysis, which incorporates cryosphere research, dropped from nearly 10% of the overall NASA price range in 2017 to eight.5% in 2021.

The scarcity of funding for glaciology hurts america’ potential to organize adequately for coming adjustments in water availability for hydropower and normal use from important western U.S. and Alaska glaciers. Additional, there isn’t any coordinating federal physique with a enough price range, schedule, or scope to focus glaciological analysis on decreasing uncertainty in future sea degree projections. The one federally funded program devoted to finding out sea degree is NASA’s Sea Level Change Team, which signifies that scientific issues outdoors NASA’s area of experience are researched advert hoc. Such investigations are pushed and prioritized by the curiosity and funding of particular person principal investigators relatively than by wants recognized by means of analysis coordination.

Working Collectively to Construct Resilience

The examine of our altering glaciers and ice sheets is a vital a part of the tapestry of geoscience options wanted to handle twenty first century issues like sea degree change. Sadly, social and organizational shortcomings, together with the low prioritization of funding for glaciology in america, have left huge data gaps, making it far more tough for scientists to offer the very best projections of ice loss and local-scale impacts to decisionmakers liable for planning responses to those issues.

We envision improved cross-agency group and funding resulting in a extra complete understanding of glacial processes and ice loss throughout your entire globe. Though cryosphere researchers collect to current analysis at many annual venues, we not often meet to debate future analysis priorities. Given the present funding panorama, we suggest holding common, open discussions to facilitate deeper reflection on the vital analysis wanted. Inside these conferences, glaciologists should debate, resolve on, after which disseminate near- and long-term analysis priorities for funding that concentrate on important observational, data, and modeling gaps. These priorities ought to embrace long-term applications to observe the local weather situations affecting ice sheets, observational applications aimed toward bettering our understanding of outlet glacier terminus and basal processes, and intensified ice sheet mannequin improvement to combine these observational efforts.

Lowering useful resource shortage and bettering cross-agency group can speed up a shift from aggressive, isolationist tendencies to collaborative work that promotes speedy progress towards filling glaciological data gaps.

We additionally argue for extra funding for glaciological analysis. Purposeful, profitable investments in such work, scaled to match the excessive stakes of rising sea ranges and different penalties of ice loss, are potential. NASA’s lately accomplished airborne mission Operation IceBridge is one instance of how such funding can yield vital outcomes. IceBridge spanned the observational hole between the ICESat (2003–2009) and ICESat-2 (launched in 2018) satellite tv for pc missions to survey Earth’s quickly altering icescapes throughout the Arctic and Antarctic [MacGregor et al., 2021]. New knowledge collected throughout IceBridge revolutionized how researchers perceive ice sheet habits and supplied crucial knowledge on ice quantity loss. One other instance is the International Thwaites Glacier Collaboration, which has supplied collaborative worldwide funding and logistical help to research probably the most tough to review and extremely changeable components of Antarctica.

Lowering useful resource shortage and bettering cross-agency group can speed up a shift from aggressive, isolationist tendencies to collaborative work that promotes speedy progress towards filling glaciological data gaps. Glaciologists are largely siloed inside their universities, and the present funding surroundings incentivizes them to stay siloed to guard their analysis and acquire an edge within the hypercompetitive grant proposal area. Extra funding alternatives would scale back this competitors and the incentives to function alone. Cross-agency funding initiatives—involving NASA, NSF, NOAA, USGS, the Military Corps of Engineers, and the Division of Protection—targeted on sea degree science are wanted to

  • encourage collaboration amongst glaciologists and between glaciologists and researchers in different disciplines
  • present vital help for observational research, monitoring, and modeling of ice sheets and coastal change
  • help coordination between sea degree scientists and coverage specialists and others in authorities, nongovernment, and trade organizations who’re educated about find out how to apply sea degree science for societal issues [Ultee et al., 2018]

Glaciologists dedicate their careers to advancing understanding of the bodily processes controlling glaciers and ice sheets—work that vitally informs projections of sea degree in addition to different potential impacts of ice loss on ecosystems and human well-being. With improved group and elevated monetary sources, present analysis and monitoring can seed expanded efforts that can assist america fill vital gaps in scientific understanding and construct resilience to the implications of ice loss for your entire world.


The authors thank the members of the glaciology analysis group who’ve agreed with the opinions expressed on this article by signing their names to this hyperlinked list. We additionally thank Caitlyn Florentine for initiating the dialog and being a part of the numerous useful discussions that led to the publication of this text.


Aschwanden, A., et al. (2021), A roadmap in direction of credible projections of ice sheet contribution to sea degree, Cryosphere, 15, 5,705–5,715,

Bernard, R. E., and E. H. G. Cooperdock (2018), No progress on range in 40 years, Nat. Geosci., 11, 292–295,

Catania, G. A., et al. (2020), Future evolution of Greenland’s marine-terminating outlet glaciers, J. Geophys. Res. Earth Surf., 125(2), e2018JF004873,

Dutt, Ok. (2020), Race and racism within the geosciences, Nat. Geosci., 13, 2–3,

Hock, R., J. Ok. Hutchings, and M. Lehning (2017), Grand challenges in cryospheric sciences: Towards higher predictability of glaciers, snow and sea ice, Entrance. Earth Sci., 5, 64,

Huss, M., et al. (2017), Towards mountains with out everlasting snow and ice, Earth’s Future, 5(5), 418–435,

MacGregor, J. A., et al. (2021), The scientific legacy of NASA’s Operation IceBridge, Rev. Geophys., 59(2), e2020RG000712,

Neumann, J. E., et al. (2015), Joint results of storm surge and sea-level rise on US coasts: New financial estimates of impacts, adaptation, and advantages of mitigation coverage, Clim. Change, 129, 337–349,

Noble, T. L., et al. (2020), The sensitivity of the Antarctic ice sheet to a altering local weather: Previous, current, and future, Rev. Geophys., 58(4), e2019RG000663,

Pitman, Ok. J., et al. (2021), Glacier retreat creating new Pacific salmon habitat in western North America, Nat. Commun., 12, 6816,

Straneo, F., et al. (2019), The case for a sustained Greenland Ice Sheet–Ocean Observing System (GrIOOS), Entrance. Mar. Sci., 6, 138,

Ultee, L., et al. (2018), From ice sheets to major streets: Intermediaries join local weather scientists to coastal adaptation, Earth’s Future, 6(3), 299–304,

Wing, O. E. J., et al. (2022), Inequitable patterns of US flood threat within the Anthropocene, Nat. Clim. Change, 12, 156–162,

Writer Info

Ginny Catania ([email protected]), College of Texas at Austin; Twila Moon, College of Colorado Boulder; and Andy Aschwanden, College of Alaska Fairbanks

Quotation: Catania, G., T. Moon, and A. Aschwanden (2022), Glacial data gaps impede resilience to sea degree rise, Eos, 103, Revealed on 11 Could 2022.
This text doesn’t signify the opinion of AGU, Eos, or any of its associates. It’s solely the opinion of the creator.
Textual content © 2022. The authors. CC BY-NC-ND 3.0
Besides the place in any other case famous, photographs are topic to copyright. Any reuse with out categorical permission from the copyright proprietor is prohibited.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here