New Zealand courtroom grants China’s extradition request for homicide suspect


Chinese language authorities accuse Kyung Yup Kim, a South Korean citizen who has everlasting residency in New Zealand, of killing a lady in Shanghai in 2009, based on courtroom paperwork.

in article 1
China first requested his extradition from New Zealand in 2011, however Kim’s legal professionals argued he might face torture and wouldn’t obtain a good trial beneath the nation’s murky judicial system, prompting years of authorized wrangling.

Like many Western nations, together with america and the UK, New Zealand doesn’t have an extradition treaty with China.

In its resolution, New Zealand’s Supreme Courtroom dominated by three judges to 2 that Kim’s extradition ought to proceed. The three judges in favor stated that they had acquired enough assurances from China and have been “happy that there was no actual threat Mr. Kim would face an unfair trial.”

Chinese language authorities had assured the courtroom that if extradited, Kim would have entry to New Zealand consular workers, and be tried and detained in Shanghai slightly than despatched elsewhere within the nation, based on the ruling.

The courtroom added it felt assured China would stick with its phrase, citing “the power of (China’s) motivation to honor the assurances” and “the power of the bilateral relationship between the 2 nations.”

Kim’s legal professionals had argued the high-profile nature of this case and its sensitivity to Chinese language authorities put him at excessive threat. Within the Wednesday ruling, the courtroom disagreed, saying he was “an extraordinary legal suspect” as a result of he “doesn’t belong to a minority group and isn’t a political prisoner.”

In an announcement to CNN, Tony Ellis, Kim’s lead lawyer, stated Kim was “very dissatisfied with the judgment.”

The staff will combat the extradition by submitting a criticism to the UN Human Rights Committee and search a recent judicial assessment if crucial, Ellis stated.

He cited the greater than two years the Supreme Courtroom had taken to succeed in its resolution and Kim’s quite a few well being points — together with extreme melancholy, a small mind tumor, and liver and kidney illnesses — as grounds to object.

After China’s preliminary extradition request in 2011, Kim had been detained for 5 years then granted bail on the situation he wore an ankle bracelet, making him the longest serving detainee with out trial in New Zealand’s fashionable historical past, Ellis stated.

The case in opposition to Kim

Kim has lived in New Zealand since he was 14 years previous, based on courtroom paperwork. His mom can also be a New Zealand everlasting resident, whereas his father, brother and two kids are residents.

The case in opposition to him dates again to December 2009, when a younger girl who labored as a waitress at a bar was discovered useless in Shanghai, based on court documents. On the time, Kim was visiting Shanghai and had rented an house there.

Items of a quilt have been discovered on her physique — which have been recognized by Kim’s then-girlfriend as much like one he owned. When police searched Kim’s house, they discovered samples that matched the waitress’ DNA.

Kim had additionally instructed a contact in a phone dialog that he could have overwhelmed a intercourse employee to dying, based on police.

Courtroom paperwork stated there was proof to counsel the waitress could have engaged in intercourse work.

Kim has denied the homicide prices.

Authorized battle

Following China’s preliminary extradition request, the New Zealand courts dominated in 2013 that Kim might be handed over and that call was confirmed two years later by the Minister of Justice. Nonetheless, Kim filed for a judicial assessment and efficiently challenged the choice.

After receiving additional assurances from China that it might deal with Kim humanely, the minister in 2016 determined to suggest Kim’s extradition a second time.

Kim as soon as once more challenged the choice — first unsuccessfully on the Excessive Courtroom then efficiently on the Courtroom of Enchantment in 2019.

The case then went to the Supreme Courtroom for a last ruling.

At the time, the Chinese language Overseas Ministry had urged New Zealand to extradite Kim “as quickly as doable, in order that justice will be upheld for the sufferer,” and defended the Chinese language judicial system as respecting “the authorized rights of legal suspects.”

In China, courts, prosecutors and police are overseen by the Chinese language Communist Social gathering’s highly effective Central Political and Authorized Affairs Fee and its native branches.

China’s judicial system has a conviction charge of about 99%, based on authorized observers. Human rights advocates say unfair trials and the torture and mistreatment of prisoners are widespread.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here