A Muslim Lady’s Reply on Home Violence


By: Dr. Kamsiah Haider

Kamsiah Haider is one in all Kuala Lumpur’s most outstanding dental surgeons and a follower of contemporary Islam. She practices multi-disciplinary dentistry in non-public follow in Kuala Lumpur after having began her profession as a College lecturer earlier than embarking on non-public follow. She additionally runs mentorship packages for younger dentists keen to amass essential abilities and experience in dental implantology. She wrote this for Asia Sentinel in response to a video launched by Siti Zailah Mohd Yusoff, the deputy minister for Girls, Household, and Neighborhood Improvement on February 11 on recommendation for married {couples} “to assist one another turn into higher individuals” that included corporal punishment.

in article 1

I’m a sufferer of home violence in a earlier marriage. I walked out of that marriage, which I used to be in a position to do due to my schooling, which happily made leaving an choice that’s not out there to far too many ladies in Malaysia.

Siti Zailah Mohd Yusoff, the deputy minister for Girls, Household, and Neighborhood Improvement, a member of the agricultural Islamist Parti Islam se-Malaysia, in her video suggests girls “converse to the husbands when they’re calm, are full and have completed consuming, have prayed, and are relaxed” and to ask permission to talk. If wives disobey their husbands, she recommends that husbands “use a bodily contact that’s light, that educates and is stuffed with love, however doesn’t trigger harm, however reveals how stern we’re in wanting to alter their habits,” she mentioned.

The recommendation by Deputy Minister Siti to husbands to make use of a “light” bodily contact if their wives are cussed strikes a delicate word for me. There isn’t any such factor as “hitting a spouse gently.” It’s tough to gauge a person’s “prowess” in his second of anger. Sure! I used to be married to a person who couldn’t handle his anger.

I’m hardly alone. A examine performed by Universiti Sains Malaysia‘s Girls’s Improvement Analysis Middle (Kanita) in 2014 discovered that 9 p.c of ever-partnered girls in Peninsular Malaysia have skilled home violence sooner or later of their lifetime. There have been 6.396 million home households in Malaysia in 2021. Extending that throughout the nation and assuming the speed of home violence stays the identical, as many as 287,000 girls may have skilled violence of some type. In 2018, the final 12 months the analysis middle equipped figures to Wiki, 5,513 circumstances have been reported to police, which is assumed to be a minuscule determine as a result of most girls, notably in a repressive society which is rising extra repressive, don’t dare go to the police. 

In making that assertion, a deputy minister who is meant to be a lawmaker is blatantly going off her public responsibility. She has no enterprise advising her sons or her sons-in-law on “touching their wives in such method,” not to mention advising the nation. As Malaysia’s former Islamic affairs minister Mujahid Yusof Rawa says, she is “clueless” about her position as a deputy minister accountable for girls’s improvement.

She ought to be centered on coverage and points like home violence, little one marriages, and social sicknesses from which this nation suffers. We will’t count on a lot from a deputy minister who’s on this place due to a political coup that eliminated a popularly elected reform coalition, Pakatan Harapan, from energy in 2020.

As way back as 2006, an advocate of girls’s rights described the standing of Muslim girls in Malaysia as just like that of black South Africans underneath apartheid. She made these remarks in response to an Islamic legislation that allows males to divorce or take as much as 4 wives and which additionally grants husbands extra authority over their wives’ property. Sharia, which severely circumscribes girls’s rights, is more and more used on this nation to disclaim girls legit and equal entry to the legislation.

The entire cabal led by those that now run the federal government has failed at their entrusted new positions. The coalition now in energy, whether or not due to its public obeisance to Islam or due to mismanagement of the economic system, has failed Malaysians, who’ve been stunned to study of allegations of leaders getting tens of million ringgit in bribes to maintain UMNO in energy underneath the earlier administration who’re concerned with worldly objects comparable to properties, high-powered bikes, costly automobiles and quantity plates bought at exorbitant costs whereas preaching deep dedication to the Quran.

PAS’s hudud merry-go-round, through which they want to return Malaysia to sixth-century Arab legislation to punish a liberal Southeast Asia Malay society, reveals one other type of corruption, i.e. corruption of data.

So the deputy minister’s remark within the midst of a failing nation is nothing however a political stunt. This really epitomizes PAS’s delusion. This type of corruption could be very harmful to this nation. The holy Quran comprises tens of verses on kindness to girls (30:21; 9:71; 16:90; 2:229-237, 4:19; 4:25 ). It emphasizes repeatedly to indicate love, kindness and warns males that they need to not hurt their wives even after divorce.

Marriage within the Islamic context is a method of tranquility, safety, peace, and luxury. Abuse of any form is in battle with the rules of marriage. Certainly not is violence towards girls inspired or allowed in Islam. These sorts of “ideas” the deputy minister espouses in her video will not be warranted on this twenty first century to self-discipline wives for “unruly” habits. In right this moment’s Malay Muslim Malaysian society, most of us rely upon twin incomes.

Clearly, there are declines in conventional household circumstances the place the husband beforehand was the only real breadwinner. However none of them warrant disciplining with bodily punishment. No affordable girl would count on to be in a relationship which is unable to convey love however moderately inequality and violence. These uncalled-for “ideas” on marriage are unacceptable and deplorable. She ought to simply follow her day job.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here